Ezekiel Emanuel at JSPAN Annual Meeting: Optimistic on America's Healthcare
By Deborah Weinstein
The Jewish Social Action Policy Network held its 2012 Annual Meeting at the Pyramid Club in Center City Philadelphia on June 6, 2012. Guest speaker, bioethicist
Ezekiel J. Emanuel, M.D., Ph.D., captivated his audience with the many reasons he is "optimistic about the future of the American healthcare system" and why he
believes that it will be "vastly improved" by the end of the decade.
Dr. Emanuel expressed confidence that the U.S. Supreme Court will find the Affordable Care Act constitutional when the Justices hand down their decision on the
healthcare reform law later this month. In his view, there is "No doubt it is constitutional." "Legally, this is an open and shut case," he said.
The Court can and, he believes, will uphold the Act on grounds relating to the Necessary and Proper Clause, the Commerce Clause and the federal government's taxing
powers. Extolling the landmark passage of the Act by Congress (which he helped to craft), Emanuel traced what he described as "100 years of effort" by former U.S.
Presidents and others to reform the country's healthcare system.
The new chair of the Department of Medical Ethics at the University of Pennsylvania and Vice-Provost for Global Initiatives, Emanuel is also an Op-Ed contributor to
The New York Times and founding chair of the Department of Bioethics at the National Institute of Health. During the Obama administration's development of the
Affordable Care Act, he served as a Special Advisor on Health Policy to the Director of the Office of Management and Budget and on the National Economic Council.
Dr. Emanuel began his remarks by focusing on the magnitude of the cost of the country's healthcare system, which he said is the largest in the world. According to
Emanuel, in 2010, the country spent $2.6 trillion dollars on healthcare, up to 50 per cent more per person than the two other highest-spending countries, Norway and
Switzerland. The level of U.S. healthcare spending makes it the fifth largest economy in the world. It is growing by $100 million every year.
Despite this level of spending, Emanuel dubbed the quality of healthcare in this country as "average, no matter how you measure it." "On no metric is this a
healthcare system we should be proud of," he said. It is a system that "doesn't cover 50 million Americans" and where there is a 20 per cent chance of re-admission to
a hospital within 30 days after discharge. This, he said, is both "indefensible" and "unacceptable."
Viewing the present time as a "transition period when there is a lot of uncertainty and change," Dr. Emanuel believes the system will be vastly improved by 2020. He
envisions a healthcare system of the future that will be more cost conscious, more focused on higher quality of care and designed to provide less unnecessary care. He
predicted that the healthcare system in this country will do a better job of coordinating care and rely on improved metrics about quality of care and assessment of
doctors. "Comparative effectiveness research," he said, "will provide us with better understanding of what treatments work. We have examples of systems that work" and
know "solutions exist already." The challenges going forward as Dr. Emanuel sees it will be to "invent ways to replicate solutions."
At the conclusion of his presentation, Dr. Emanuel took questions from the audience, including long-time JSPAN members and guests. JSPAN Board President Brian
Gralnick and incoming President Lynn Zeitlin, Esquire, concluded the formal portion of the program with a brief discussion of JSPAN, what its mission is as an
organization, the impact it has already had, and how it plans to expand its reach in the future. President Zeitlin also recognized outgoing Board Treasurer Stephen
Applebaum and JSPAN Policy Center Chair Susan Myers for their valuable contributions and diligent work for the organization.
JSPAN Board Welcomes New Officers and Directors|
The JSPAN Board of Directors is pleased to welcome three new Directors: Adrienne Jacoby, Rabbi George Stern and Hon. Babette Josephs. The Board also announced the
election of JSPAN officers for the coming year including: President, Lynn Zeitlin, Esquire; Vice Presidents, Judah Labovitz, Esquire, Mark Newman and Burt Siegel;
Secretary/General Counsel, Stewart Weintraub, Esquire and Treasurer, Ken Myers, Esquire. The Board also extends its appreciation for the valuable and important work
of Susan Myers who is stepping down as JSPAN Policy Center Chair and Stephen Applebaum who has served as the organization's Treasurer.
JSPAN Opposes PA Whole Women's Health Funding Priorities Act, HB
The JSPAN Board of Directors recently approved a resolution opposing Pennsylvania House Bill 2405, "The Whole Women's Health Funding Priorities Act" and any other
efforts to defund family planning services in Pennsylvania, as follows:
"JSPAN opposes House Bill 2405 and any attempts to remove public funding for family planning providers who perform abortions like Planned Parenthood. JSPAN recognizes
the life-saving services offered by these healthcare providers and is extremely concerned with the public health crisis that could ensure should the funding be
eliminated. Women turn to these providers for their annual gynecological exams, breast wellness exams, cervical cancer screenings, STI testing and treatment,
pregnancy prevention, high blood pressure screening and smoking cessation programs. Thousands of women throughout Pennsylvania will have nowhere to turn for
affordable, high-quality preventive health services especially during a time when many are uninsured or underinsured. JSPAN opposes taking away vital, life-saving
services and any other effort to defund family planning services in Pennsylvania."
Bill Would Steer Pennsylvania State Funds Away from Planned
By Michael Macagnone|
May 23, 2012
HARRISBURG -- State money would be steered away from Planned Parenthood and other healthcare providers that perform abortions in Pennsylvania under a state House
proposal unveiled today.
Rep. Daryl Metcalfe, R-Cranberry, said the bill would end the "flow of taxpayer money to support abortionists" during a press conference introducing the bill.
What's So Jewish about Father's Day?|
Posted on May 13, 2012|
The PJ Library Blog
HONORING OUR FATHERS AND MOTHERS is an everyday Mitzvah. So, what's particularly Jewish about the third Sunday in June?
EVERDAY FATHER'S DAY
The fifth Commandment tells us clearly we must honor our parents. According to traditional Jewish understanding, this means honoring them not just on one day, but
every day. Does this mean Father's Day is an unnecessary holiday?
Rabbi Brad Hirschfield tries to answer this question (and other related ones) in his New York Jewish Week opinion piece, titled "Father's Day: It's a Mitzvah."
According to Rabbi Hirschfield, Father's Day presents an opportunity to reconnect with the everyday commandment, along with our parents themselves.
Who Are Our Jewish Fathers?|
By Leah Berkenwald|
The Jewish Daily Forward
The Sisterhood Blog: Where Jewish Women Converse
June 12, 2012
In a blog post last week Gabrielle Orcha asked, "What about the Jewish father? … Who is he really?"
With Father's Day coming up this weekend, we wanted to start a dialogue about the Jewish fathers, or fathers (who may or may not be Jewish) of Jewish daughters. We put
out a call for Jewish daughters to tell us about their fathers. We'd also like to thank the folks at Kveller.com, who took up the call and helped collect these
Silencing of the Liberal American Jew: We've Allowed Noisy Minorities to
Censor Our Voices|
By J. J. Goldberg|
The Jewish Daily Forward
June 08, 2012
When Miami's Temple Israel canceled a scheduled Memorial Day talk by local Democratic Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz, following a protest by a wealthy Republican donor,
it did more than just insult an elected official. It laid down a significant new marker in the gradual silencing of American Jewry as a moral voice in the broader
The silencing has been so gradual, and so thorough, that few even notice it anymore. There was a time - for about a half-century after World War II - when the Jewish
community's main representative bodies played a leading role in national struggles for tolerance and equal rights, fighting for Jews and non-Jews alike. Combining
organizational savvy, generous donors, a motivated base and the moral authority of history's victims, the community gained a standing and clout beyond its numbers. And
the nation was better for it.
Jewish Community for Peacemaking & Against Divestment: Calling on
Presbyterians to Embrace Peacemaking and Reject Divestment|
At the end of June, delegates to the Presbyterian Church (PCUSA) will gather in Pittsburgh for their General Assembly. Church leaders will consider a report that
calls for divestment from three companies for their sales to Israel. Please join us in calling on Presbyterians to embrace peacemaking and reject divestment.
This letter builds on one signed by 1,300 American Rabbis from all four religious streams and all 50 states sent to church delegates. Join us in urging the PCUSA to
take positive steps to provide Palestinians and Israelis peace and security embodied in a two-state solution.
PCA Says New DPW Regulations Pose a Threat to the Most
June 5, 2012
New regulations will go into effect July 1 that officials at Philadelphia Corporation for Aging (PCA) say will endanger the health, welfare and safety of more than
8,400 frail, homebound senior citizens in Philadelphia - and more than 20,000 seniors across the Commonwealth.
"The safety net that Pennsylvania's most vulnerable seniors need and deserve is being shredded by policy decisions from the Department of Public Welfare which
jeopardize our ability to serve them most effectively," said PCA President Rodney D. Williams.
These are seniors who are entitled to nursing home care, paid for by Medicaid. They are all frail and physically disabled; many are also mentally compromised. In a
nursing home, they would have nursing care available at all times. They have, instead, opted to remain in their own homes, with the services of the Aging Waiver
Your Opinion Counts|
The editors of the JSPAN newsletter welcome reader's comments regarding the content and format of the newsletter. We want to know what you like and dislike. Are we
providing a perspective and service that you find informative and worth reading? Do you have comments on specific articles or items? Let us know what you think!
Send all comments to firstname.lastname@example.org
Remember that JSPAN welcomes your donations to help us continue our important and effective work in Tikkun Olam. You may send gifts via PayPal on www.jspan.org. or to JSPAN, 1735 Market Street, Suite #A417, Philadelphia, PA 19103
Want to Join?
To become a JSPAN member, please go to www.JSPAN.org. On the right side of your screen
you will be able to start a secure transaction and become a member.
Make all checks payable to:
1735 Market Street, Suite #A417
Philadelphia, PA 19103
First Vice President
Secretary & General Counsel
Policy Centers Chair
Chair of the Board of Directors
David S. Broida
Hon. Ruth Damsker
Rabbi Elliot Holin
Rabbi Robert Layman
Richard I. Malkin
Audrey Ann Ross
J. Sanford Schwartz
Rabbi David Straus
Rabbi Joshua Waxman
Jill Katz Zipin