Click to view this email in a browser

Hiddush CEO Rabbi Uri Regev & Chairman Stanley P. Gold

A message from Hiddush

Sept. 7, 2017
16 Elul, 5777

Dear Friends,

Next week, Hiddush's annual Israel Religion & State Index will be published, and it will become clear just how much the gap between the public's will and the policies of Israel's elected official's has increased. The public yearns for the realization of the promise enshrined in Israel's Declaration of Independence for freedom of religion and equality. Not only does Israel's political leadership refuse to realize this, but it perpetually surrenders these values and freedoms to the ultra-Orthodox political establishment, be it in policy, in budget allocations, or in legislation.

This issue took center stage again last week at the Supreme Court when government representatives tried to defend the "freezing" (non-implementation) of the government's Western Wall agreement. They attempted to justify why freedom of worship and equality for all Jews shouldn't be allowed at the Western Wall. More recently, the government submitted a response to a petition that will be heard by the Court next week regarding public transportation on Shabbat, which was submitted by Hiddush and other partnering organizations. The state is arguing that there is no real need for public transportation on Shabbat - and that the state does not intend (nor is it required) to conduct a survey of the public's needs in this matter.

Further examples of the fundamentalist religious establishment's corruption came to light this week.

It became known that in the last two years, during which 178 kashrut inspectors were appointed by the Rabbinate, not one woman was appointed to this post... despite the Court having ordered that women should not be discriminated against as kashrut supervisors, and despite the Chief Rabbinate having confirmed that this is not prohibited.

Also, the owner of the Jerusalem tea house Halitatea was surprised to learn he would have to pay more to keep his kashrut certificate from the Chief Rabbinate because his new business partner is of Russian descent. The kashrut supervisor told him: "I don't like the looks of him, he's Russian, I don't trust him."

And this week it also came to light that the only mohel in Mitzpeh Ramon, after agreeing to perform a circumcision for a newborn on Shabbat, refused to keep his word because he claimed that the child was not Jewish! Why did he refuse? Apparently, the mother underwent an Orthodox conversion during her IDF services but does not observe Shabbat, and the mohel proclaimed his doubt of her Jewish 'status' and that of her children. The parents were forced to cancel the brit and could not get another a mohel because it was Shabbat. They suffered from both injury and insult because of the cancellation of their event and because of the doubt of their Judaism.

Such wrongs occur every week. Some are publicized and others do not reach the public's attention, but the lesson is always the same: The time has come to realize full freedom of religion and equality in Israel!

All the very best,

Stanley P. Gold,
Hiddush Chair

Rabbi Uri Regev,
Hiddush President

Make your impact today

Make an impact that will last. Your financial support of Hiddush advances freedom of religion and equality in Israel

donate to Hiddush


The Bitter Taste of Victory
by Rabbi Pamela Frydman

On August 31st, the Israeli Supreme Court ruled on a matter brought by the Reform and Conservative Movements, Women of the Wall, Hiddush and Yisrael Hofshit regarding whether to require the government to adhere to the Kotel agreement.

Click HERE for full article

This guest post was written by Rabbi Pam Frydman, Coordinator of the Beyond Genocide Campaign of the Board of Rabbis of Northern California and Chair of Rabbis for Religious Freedom and Equality in Israel.

When we let ourselves experience the hatred between Ultra-Orthodox and non-Orthodox, it is clear that Israel and our Jewish future are at risk. Anyone who thinks otherwise what would do well to think again. Without the Jewish lobby in North America, I shudder to think of Israel’s future in a few hundred years.

Some refer to the hatred between us as sinat hinam, but the price is actually quite high. To improve our future, we need a different narrative that teaches our children that there are lots of ways to be Jewish and those who observe differently are also Jews. If we teach our children to love the stranger, we can also teach them to love fellow Jews.

On August 31st, the Israeli Supreme Court ruled on a matter brought by the Reform and Conservative Movements, Women of the Wall, Hiddush and Yisrael Hofshit regarding whether to require the government to adhere to the Kotel agreement that provides for a dignified egalitarian prayer space and a second space for women who wish to pray separately with tallit, tefillin and reading from a sefer Torah. The government negotiated the agreement, signed it and then rescinded and froze it, because Ultra-Orthodox members of Knesset threatened to leave the government if the agreement is implemented.

During the August 31 hearing, the Supreme Court ordered the Prime Minister to reconsider the freeze and gave the government 14 days to agree to unfreeze the agreement or show whether there is a legal method to force the State to uphold the agreement.

Why are the Ultra-Orthodox frightened by a few Conservative and Reform leaders and Women of the Wall? Because their role at the Kotel would spell the end of the Ultra-Orthodox monopoly over publicly decided religious matters. The Ultra-Orthodox force the government to pay salaries to non-Orthodox rabbis through the Department of Sports and Culture rather than through the Rabbinate. They avoid convening (administrative) Rabbinic Councils to which non-Orthodox and women have been elected or appointed. But they cannot avoid jointly administering the Kotel without risking that the Kotel will be administered without them. That is why the August 31 Supreme Court decision represents such a threat to for them and a victory for pluralism.


The encouragingly innovative opinion
of Justice Anat Baron

The Court has consistently, for decades, rejected petitions to order the state to institute civil marriage and/or allow non-Orthodox religious marriage and/or recognize marriages performed outside the auspices of the Chief Rabbinate. The recurring argument is that the address for the solution is the Knesset, rather than the Court.

Since Israel's 1992 Basic Law: 'Human Dignity and Liberty' was enacted, which allowed the Supreme Court to annul laws that contradict these fundamental principles, the Court has pointed to the "grandfather clause" which states that the validity of laws enacted prior to the Basic Law would not be affected even if they contradict the binding principles set out therein.

Nevertheless, the ruling included the interesting and encouragingly innovative opinion of Justice Anat Baron. She hinted that perhaps the time had come to set an expiration date for cases of discriminatory laws. Unlike her colleagues, she expressed clear and open support for the rights of the petitioners and of Israelis in general to marry freely in their country. In her submitted opinion, Justice Baron wrote about relations between religion and state in general and the right to marry in particular:

    ... An indefinite "encirclement" of the laws of personal status from constitutional scrutiny, through the provision of the preservation of laws, is difficult. Justice Prof. Aharon Barak emphasized that this creates an anomaly that is not desirable in our legal system: "... Two sets of laws - old and new - exist side by side without one bringing about the change or cancellation of the other." This is the product of a political compromise. However, it creates a constitutional anomaly. This is not a healthy situation for a legal system. Modern democratic constitutions do not include a provision on the preservation of [old] laws. On the contrary, they are based on... recognition that the present and the future are good for us. This has not been the [trajectory of] Israel's [legal] development...


Hiddush in the Media


Support Hiddush

donate Icon
Donate to
volunteer Icon
Volunteer to
tell your story Icon
Share your
facebook icon
Join Hiddush
on Facebook
blog Icon
Start your
Hiddush Blog

Hiddush - Freedom of Religion for Israel, Inc.
Website:  |  Email:  |  182 East 95th St. Suite 24G, New York, NY 10128  |  Office: 646-334-5636

Sign the Vision!

Click to view this email in a browser

If you no longer wish to receive these emails, please reply to this message with "Unsubscribe" in the subject line or simply click on the following link: Unsubscribe

Freedom of Religion for Israel
182 East 95th St., Suite 24G
New York, New York 10128

Read the VerticalResponse marketing policy.

Non-Profits Email Free with VerticalResponse!